In the Spotlight The Knowledge Loom Home Page About Search Feedback Site Map Partners
The Knowledge Loom - Adolescent Literacy in the Content AreasSpotlight cover page

Spotlight Cover

List of Practices

about this practice
Current page

What is it?

Stories

Research

Policy

Related Resources

Join the dialog submenus

Panel Discussion

Have Your Say

Q & A

Download/Print

Entire Spotlight

This Practice

Selections


About Printing

Log in
Register



THE PRACTICE: Roles of the Teacher


Content Presented By:
Center for Resource Management (CRM) content provider logo
The Education Alliance at Brown University content provider logo

What Is It?
Suggested Strategies and Resources: Context
Suggested Strategies and Resources: Explicit Instruction
Suggested Strategies and Resources: Modeling
Suggested Strategies and Resources: Multiple Assessments
Questions to Think About

What is it?

The research suggests that instructors teach literacy skills and strategies in context rather than in isolation. This suggestion contradicts the practice of using "skill and drill" worksheets for remediation. There is ample evidence to confirm that a number of particular literacy strategies--when explicitly taught, modeled, and practiced-- enhance the ability of secondary students to read and write across the content areas. These include pre-reading activities, such as the activation of prior knowledge. Research also confirms the effectiveness of modeling and the use of a literacy apprenticeship framework. Finally, it is crucial that teachers and students use information provided by a variety of assessment strategies to inform literacy instruction; this information is critical to the improvement of literacy skills.

Top

Suggested Strategies and Resources: Context

Students learn skills in context.
Research shows that better results occur when students learn skills in conjunction with examples and teachers stress the relevance and usefulness of these skills to students' lives. It does not show strong results for students who learn skills in isolation and are then expected to apply/transfer them appropriately at their own discretion.

For lesson plans secondary teachers can use to teach reading strategies, please see http://www.ops.org/reading/secondarystrat1.htm

This site also shows how reading comprehension strategies can be used as part of content area learning:
http://www.inspiringteachers.com/classroom_resources/tips/curriculum_and_instruction/reading_strategies.html

Suggested Strategies and Resources: Explicit Instruction

Students learn reading comprehension strategies through explicit instruction.
Research clearly supports the teaching and use of a variety of reading comprehension strategies with adolescents before, during, and after reading. These include: use of Anticipation Guides, Directed Reading and Teaching Activity (DRTA), Reciprocal Teaching, KWL, Graphic Organizers, Think Aloud, Question Generating, Sensory Imagery, Drama, Art, and structured note-taking.

Descriptions of strategies that support reading comprehension can be found at the following websites:
http://www.litandlearn.lpb.org/strategies.html
http://www.howard.k12.md.us/langarts/Curriculum/strategies.htm
http://curry.edschool.virginia.edu/go/readquest/strat/

A description of Reciprocal Teaching can be found at
http://ncrel.org/sdrs/areas/issues/students/atrisk/at6lk38.htm

An example of an Anticipation/Reaction Guide can be found at
http://www.indiana.edu/~l517/anticipation_guides.htm

Collections of Graphic Organizers can be found at
http://www.indiana.edu/~reading/ieo/bibs/graphsec.html
http://ncrel.org/sdrs/areas/issues/students/learning/lr1grorg.htm
http://graphic.org/goindex.html
http://www.sdcoe.k12.ca.us/score/actbank/torganiz.htm
http://curry.edschool.virginia.edu/go/readquest/strat/graphic.html

See examples of vocabulary and concept development through concept mapping for science, math, and social studies at
http://www.strategictransitions.com/educationalapplications.htm

A reading strategies database describing general and specific reading comprehension strategies related to before, during, and after reading, vocabulary, motivation, text structure, and more can be found at
http://www.muskingum.edu/~cal/database/readingcomp.html and http://www.edletter.org/past/issues/1999-ja/secondary.shtml

Top

Suggested Strategies and Resources: Modeling

Teachers frequently use modeling/apprenticeship as a teaching technique and framework.
Reading and writing are complex combinations of skills that vary by context. Reading a scientific journal does not require the same set of skills as reading a historical novel. Writing geometric proofs, lab reports, short stories, poems, and persuasive letters requires overlapping but not identical sets of skills. Moreover, people who are proficient in some aspects of reading and writing are novices at others. It is important for students to see themselves and their classmates as developing readers and writers, continually trying to learn the craft. Teachers can effectively support literacy development by making visible their own processes as more expert readers and writers in their respective fields.

The Strategic Literacy Initiative has developed several strategies that are for both general and discipline-specific use.

--For a strategy to use across the curriculum, see "Reading Process Analysis" at
http://wested.org/stratlit/ideas/readingprocess.shtml.

--For a strategy to use in the English classroom, see "This is About..." at
http://wested.org/stratlit/ideas/englishappren.shtml.

--For a strategy to use in the Science classroom, see "Creating a Twenty-five Word Abstract" at
http://wested.org/stratlit/ideas/twentyfiveword.shtml.

--For an example from a Social Studies classroom, see "A Metacognitive Double-Entry Journal" at
http://wested.org/stratlit/ideas/whatnhow.shtml.

--For a list of ideas for how to motivate students to read and suggestions for how to establish a culture of reading in school, see http://www.bcps.org/offices/lis/models/tips/readingpage/motivation.html

--For a discussion of implementation factors that affect SSR effectiveness, see http://www.readingonline.org/articles/art_index.asp?HREF=/articles/nagy/index.html

Top

Suggested Strategies and Resources: Multiple Assessments

Teachers use a variety of assessment strategies and tools.
Literacy assessment tools provide ongoing feedback; teachers use this feedback to plan instruction and students use it to gauge progress in reading and writing. Literacy assessment tools include rubrics, self-assessment inventories, observation, learning logs/journals, Individualized Reading Inventories (IRIs), cloze passages, teacher-created assignments, and (where appropriate or mandated) standardized or standards-based tests.

For descriptions of a variety of reading assessment strategies,
see
http://instech.tusd.k12.az.us/balancedlit/handbook/BLHS/blasmths.htm.

For an online tool to assist with developing rubrics,
see http://rubistar.4teachers.org/.

For numerous reading strategies and a guide to the literacy learning needs of bilingual learners, see "RICA & the Literacy Learning Needs of Bilingual Readers" at
http://coe.sdsu.edu/people/jmora/RICAprep.htm#Domains.

Top

Questions to Think About:

Before you can implement this Key Component, your stakeholders will need to consider some or all of these questions. Use them for group discussions, needs-sensing activities, and informal small-group conversations.

  • Which of the above best practices typically occur now as part of teaching and learning? Which do not? Why do you think that is the case?

  • How would teaching and learning shift if the above best practices characterized education throughout the school? How would time, space, personnel, and materials/resources be used differently?

  • What kind of support would teachers need in order to effectively incorporate these practices into teaching and learning on a daily basis?

  • If these practices were to characterize what takes place in classrooms throughout the school, would any current instructional benefits be displaced or compromised?
Top